Netflix's new no.1 thriller deserves more than its 41% Rotten Tomatoes score

EntertainmentStreamingNetflix’s new no.1 thriller deserves more than its 41% Rotten Tomatoes scoreShame on youWhen you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.

Shame on you

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: Netflix)

Fool Me Once

(Image credit: Netflix)

2023 was the year I finally let the thriller genre sink its teeth into me,A Murder at The End Of The WorldandCulpritswere two excellentDisney+ series that weren’t my usual kind of watch. Now I’m left with another obsession in a similar mould, and it’s currently the most popular show onNetflixUK.

What’s interesting aboutFool Me Onceis that initially, I was completely uninterested, the first ten minutes didn’t really grab me, the direction was a bit flat and the characters seemed fairly generic. A quick check onRotten Tomatoesrevealed a poor 41% audience score and I was quite happy to move on. After a friend’s recommendation, however, I gave the Michelle Keegan-led murder mystery another chance and was pleasantly surprised.

An adaption of the Harlan Coben novel of the same name, we follow Maya, an army veteran who is now unfortunately a widower with her husband Joe having been murdered. We start with his funeral. but when he turns up on the nanny cam, playing with their daughter, Maya understandably has questions.

Given her traumatic past, both the authorities and Maya’s friends and family (including mother-in-law Joanna Lumley) don’t exactly believe her, and there’s a lot of gaslighting that it’s just grief and trauma playing tricks on her. Women trying to get people to believe them is an interesting angle, and one that obviously has important parallels in real life. It’s also fresh to see a woman portrayed as a real, flawed, human. Maya is far from a Mary Sue, she has serious anger issues and resorts to physical confrontation far too quickly.

I’m only a couple of episodes in but my breakout star of the show is definitely Adeel Akhtar’s Detective Sami Kierce. Akhtar is someone I mostly know through comedy and he somehow manages to bring some levity to what is otherwise a pretty deadly serious show. His grumblings at the youth of his partner were particularly funny (he has his phone number saved as “the child”).

IsFool Me Oncegoing to be the best show of 2024? Almost certainly not, but it is worth your time this January.

Today’s best Netflix dealsNetflix - Standard with ads$6.99/mthViewatNetflixNetflix - Standard$15.49/mthViewatNetflixNetflix - Premium$22.99/mthViewatNetflix

Today’s best Netflix deals

Netflix - Standard with ads$6.99/mthViewatNetflixNetflix - Standard$15.49/mthViewatNetflixNetflix - Premium$22.99/mthViewatNetflix

Netflix - Standard with ads$6.99/mthViewatNetflix

Netflix

Netflix - Standard with ads

$6.99/mthView

$6.99/mth

/mth

atNetflix

Netflix - Standard$15.49/mthViewatNetflix

Netflix

Netflix - Standard

$15.49/mthView

$15.49/mth

/mth

atNetflix

Netflix - Premium$22.99/mthViewatNetflix

Netflix

Netflix - Premium

$22.99/mthView

$22.99/mth

/mth

atNetflix

Get all the latest news, reviews, deals and buying guides on gorgeous tech, home and active products from the T3 experts

TOPICSnetflix

TOPICS

Waking up for work is tough in the winter – but smart tech can help you avoid that snooze buttonHow smart tech makes winter mornings run smoother

How smart tech makes winter mornings run smoother

Hoka Bondi 9 review

Hoka Bondi 9 review: Ultimate comfort meets everyday stabilityThe latest Bondi iteration elevates max-cushioned comfort with a softer ride, improved support, and durable design

The latest Bondi iteration elevates max-cushioned comfort with a softer ride, improved support, and durable design

With Love, Meghan on Netflix

Is this the most insufferable Netflix trailer of all time?Meghan Markle has a show coming

Meghan Markle has a show coming

Cassandra on Netflix

Netflix’s sci-fi horror series looks astonishing in full trailerCassandra looks like a slow-burn horror

Cassandra looks like a slow-burn horror

Zero Day on Netflix

Two-time Oscar-winner stars in Netflix’s new thriller seriesZero Day brings Robert De Niro back to Netflix

Zero Day brings Robert De Niro back to Netflix

It Follows

3 obscure horror movies to stream on Netflix and Disney+Fancy a fright tonight? Here are our three horror flick picks you might not have thought of before

Fancy a fright tonight? Here are our three horror flick picks you might not have thought of before

Cobra Kai S6 P3

One of Netflix’s most beloved series finally confirms when it will endCobra Kai’s final part gets a date

Cobra Kai’s final part gets a date

American Primeval on Netflix

Netflix’s huge new Western series gets a super-bloody trailerAmerican Primeval looks superb but violent

American Primeval looks superb but violent

Phantom Thread

One of my favourite movies ever leaves Netflix this monthPhantom Thread is a masterpiece

Phantom Thread is a masterpiece

Back in Action on Netflix

Netflix in January: 5 top movies and shows coming to the streamerThere’s plenty to come this January on Netflix

There’s plenty to come this January on Netflix

Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox#

Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox