ActiveOutdoorsOuterwearTrail running shoes shouldn’t be waterproof – change my mindWhen it comes to running footwear, you can keep your GTX-lined gear, I’m better off without it – in more ways than oneWhen you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
ActiveOutdoorsOuterwearTrail running shoes shouldn’t be waterproof – change my mindWhen it comes to running footwear, you can keep your GTX-lined gear, I’m better off without it – in more ways than oneWhen you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
When it comes to running footwear, you can keep your GTX-lined gear, I’m better off without it – in more ways than one
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
When they’re first released, new models of running shoes – especiallytrail running shoes– are often made available in various styles with different technical specifications. Usually, the top-of-the-range (and most expensive) options have the letters GTX in the name, meaning a Gore-Tex membrane has been used in the construction of the shoe, making it waterproof.
(Other breathable waterproof membranes are, of course, available – but Gore-Tex is still the most recognisable and common component used.)
But is having a waterproof running shoe actually a good thing? Well, that depends a little bit on where you run and your personal preference, but in my opinion – no, it’s not.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Don’t get me wrong – I have nothing againstGore-Texin all itsvarious guisesor any other similar weatherproof membrane either. The way the technical fabric operates is super clever, and it does genuinely work. I’ve had very good reason to be extremely grateful to Gore-Tex during many snow-sodden and water-soaked adventures over the years, and have had the pleasure of testing its performance credentials in scenarios ranging from mid-winter ice hikes in the Cairngorms tocar-wash cascades in East London.
When it comes to seriouswaterproof jackets, properhiking bootsand substantialwalking shoes, I’m all in favour of Gore-Tex and other breathable waterproof membranes – in fact, I demand them in the gear I go out with. But running is different. I mainly run off-road, and for me and the vast majority of my trail buddies, thebest running shoesare those that are definitely not waterproof – here’s why.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Time on the trails
When hiking – whether you’re doing a multiday trek while carrying ahiking backpackor doing a day walk in a pair of hiking shoes – you typically spend many hours out on the trail. In such scenarios, it makes a lot of sense to keep your feet as dry as possible for as long as possible – not least because sodden skin can make you more susceptible to suffering blisters, which will ruin any experience.
Most trail runners, on the other hand, are only out in the wilds for one or two hours at a time (occasionally more, often less), which makes having wet feet far less of a pressing concern. This, combined with the reasons below, means that a non-waterproof version of a running shoe can make a much more pragmatic choice.
Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox
Get all the latest news, reviews, deals and buying guides on gorgeous tech, home and active products from the T3 experts
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Shoe shape and drainage
The biggest argument against wearing waterproof trail-running shoes is a pretty obvious one when you stop to think about it. A membrane that won’t let water in will also stop any unwanted liquid that does make it past the defences from getting back out.
Unlike hiking boots, which typically extend at least to the ankle, trail-running shoes are generally low-cut, usually with the collar finishing well below the ankle. So, stopping fluids from seeping into a shoe through the material of the upper is one thing, but if you’re running through wild, wet terrain with deep puddles and/or stream crossings (both very common obstacles encountered on the trails), then water and mud will quickly breach the top of the shoe and get in that way, and the waterproof membrane will keep it in.
Unless you’re prepared to stop, undo and remove your shoes, and literally pour such trail juice out, you’re going to be squelching around for the remainder of your run, which is neither pleasant nor efficient.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Ventilation and heat management
We all know that Gore-Tex and the brains and brands behind other comparable membranes make big claims about their products being breathable, and I’ve seen plenty of lab-demonstrations that prove the technology works – and tested enough boots and jackets in real conditions to know that there is ample truth in these claims. However, the fact remains, garments and footwear that aren’t waterproof are far more breathable than the ones that are. When you’re running in warm conditions it can be much more comfortable to wear thebest running socksthat have good wicking properties, combined with well-ventilated, quick-draining shoes that allow your feet to properly breathe. In my experience, waterproof shoes run very hot.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Cost
I touched on this in the first paragraph, but it’s worth mentioning again. Shoes with a waterproof membrane (be it Gore-Tex, Pertex, eVent or any of the various brand-specific iterations) cost considerably more than shoes that don’t have such a membrane. Running shoes have becomescarily expensivein recent years, and no one likes spending more money than they need to – but especially when the ingredient bumping up the price is superfluous (or even counter-active) to their performance requirements (see all the points above).
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Exceptions that prove the rule
Anker upgrades Everfrost Cooler with improved battery life and new size optionsIt now provides up to 104 hours (over four days) of cooling
It now provides up to 104 hours (over four days) of cooling
Nintendo’s crazy smart alarm clock will soon be on general saleThe playful Alarmo clock is ending online exclusivity to land in a store near you
The playful Alarmo clock is ending online exclusivity to land in a store near you
6 running mistakes beginners should avoid, according to an expertIf you want to avoid injury and improve your performance
If you want to avoid injury and improve your performance
Change my mind: the smaller, the better with portable power stationsPut your portable power station to work when you’re not using it
Put your portable power station to work when you’re not using it
This rugged adventure Garmin is mega cheap in Walmart’s Black Friday saleThe Instinct 2 is a top watch for outdoor and sport enthusiasts
The Instinct 2 is a top watch for outdoor and sport enthusiasts
YETI’s best-selling products are ridiculously cheap in Amazon’s Black Friday saleFancy yourself a tumbler, rambler or cooler? Amazon’s reduced them all
Fancy yourself a tumbler, rambler or cooler? Amazon’s reduced them all
Sore lower back after running? A physio says these three exercises can helpIf you’re prone to back aches after a run, give these a try!
If you’re prone to back aches after a run, give these a try!
The best fitness advent calendars for workout warriors and runnersStuffed with socks, protein bars and more!
Stuffed with socks, protein bars and more!
Shokz OpenRun Pro 2 review: Smart bone conduction headphones with enhanced bassShokz’s headphones changed my opinion about running while listening to music, and now I struggle to go out without them
Shokz’s headphones changed my opinion about running while listening to music, and now I struggle to go out without them
AKASO Seemor 200 night vision goggles review: unparalleled clarity for nighttime adventuresAKASO’s new NVD unlocks the night with cutting-edge colour vision technology
AKASO’s new NVD unlocks the night with cutting-edge colour vision technology
